After a year apart, teacher Jacob Peters and county judge Beau Braedon decide they can't live without each other. There are just a few small obstacles to their Alabama love story. Jacob resents Beau's paranoia about being outed, but Beau is convinced he'll lose his seat on the bench if he admits to their relationship, and as a teacher at a Christian school, Jacob's job is even more at risk. They could relocate, but Beau's mother has Alzheimer's and can't be moved. And then there's the tiny issue of Jacob's infant son, Finn, and his mother, whom Jacob wed out of duty. In short, they are stuck.
But Beau has a long-term plan, and he's prepared to swallow his fears and compromise with Jacob, because sharing stolen moments is no longer enough.